As the University of Miami football team prepares to enter spring practice in about a week, I decided to take a look at the roster, and try an deduce how I’d like to see the roster eventually take shape heading into the fall. Keep in my mind these are only my opinions, and I really hope it sparks a discussion with the Legion about how each of you feels about my thoughts, as the Canes head into the 2010 season.
Today we will take a closer look at the Hurricane Defense:
Defensive Ends
1. Allen Bailey – if not moved to DT
2. Olivier Vernon
3. Marcus Robinson
4. Adewale Ojomo
5. Steven Wesley
6. Andrew Smith
7. Dyron Dye – if not moved to TE
8. Gavin Hardin
Redshirt: David Perry
DE Thoughts: DE is one of the deepest positions on the team. There is a lot of talent on this unit, and the unit has very little drop-off as players are cycled in and out of the lineup. Allen Bailey is unquestionably the best of the bunch and is equally good at playing the run and pass. However, I see him as a strong side defensive end due to his ability to hold up at the point of attack because of his great size and strength. However, Bailey is also adept at getting after the QB, evidenced by leading the team in sacks, as he has cat like quickness. Still, Miami Defensive Coordinator, John Lovett, has been on record as saying that he’d like Bailey inside at the DT position. There is such a wealth of talent at the DE position, and that leads me to believe that what Lovett is trying to accomplish, is getting his best 4 DL on the field at the same time. This would mean Bailey on the inside, as he’s the only DE on the roster that physically is able to deal with physical nature of playing the DT position. With that said, I still have to say I disagree with Coach Lovett. Bailey has proven to be much more effective at DE than DT in my opinion.
If Bailey is moved to the DT position, I’d expect Adewale Ojomo to get the next look at strong side DE. Ojomo was rounding into shape during the 2008 season, and showed flashes of being a force on the defensive line. However, an unfortunate incident with another teammate ended his season before it began in 2009. If Ojomo can come back in top form, he will see plenty of playing time in the fall, and if Bailey is moved to DT, perhaps start on the strong side at DE. Steven Wesley has always been solid when he’s had a chance to play and is a solid contributor. Expect to see him in the rotation as well on the strong side.
The competition at the weak side defensive end (rush end) spot is going to be fierce. Sophomore Olivier Vernon played quite a bit last year and showed why he was such a heavily recruited player. He has a great first step and at 6-3, 250 lbs is physically strong enough to also play the run. I’d give him a slight edge going into the spring as the starter on the weak side. However, don’t forget about Junior Marcus Robinson. A lot was expected from Robinson last season after being named a Freshman All-America in 2008; however, he battled nagging injuries throughout the course of last season that limited his production. He is blessed with a ton of physical talent and is perhaps the Canes best pass rusher off the edge. His weakness however has been in the run game, where at 237 lbs, he has not been particularly strong in the run game, and he struggles at times at the point of attack. In the end both Vernon and Robinson will play extensively and no matter who starts, Canes fans should be excited by seeing either of those guys on the weak side.
Further depth will be provided by Andrew Smith, who has played quite a bit in his 2 years at Miami, and if he’s not moved to TE, 2009 signee Dyron Dye. Gavin Hardin is a question mark, as his future in football has been questioned due to a severe neck injury that has plagued him the last 2 seasons. He isn’t listed on the spring injury report as out, so I’d expect him to be participating at this point. Incoming freshman, David Perry, will most likely redshirt. Perry has a lot of natural ability, but is new to the game and will need time to develop at this level.
Defensive Tackle
1. Marcus Forston
2. Micanor Regis
3. Josh Holmes
4. Curtis Porter
5. Jeremy Lewis
6. Luther Robinson
Redshirt: Jeffery Brown and Delmar Taylor
DT Thoughts: Historically, Miami has always been known for having great DT play. However, in recent years, the play at DT has tailed off a bit. Marcus Forston was expected to have a breakout season after also garnering accolades as a Freshman All-America, but battled injuries and was ineffective during the first few games of 2009. He recently had surgery and is expected to have limited participation in the spring. The Canes really need Forston to become a dominating force from the DT position. Forston has the talent, as he blessed with good size, good strength, and good quickness. But he’s always faced concerns about his motor, and the effort he gives on each and every play. At times he shows flashes, while at other times he disappears. If he can stay healthy and become the consistent dominating force he was in HS, the defense will benefit greatly from his increased production as a pass rusher, as he will be the type of player that demands a double team.
Micanor Regis played well when given the opportunity. He is big and strong and holds up well at the point. I’d expect Regis to be a run stopping type DT that can help collapse the pocket. Regis also has an uncanny ability to be in the right place at the right time, as he demonstrated by recording 2 INTs last season off of tipped passes.
Josh Holmes, after getting healthy, played extensively last season. Holmes has good quickness but lacks ideal size. He is a contributor and if Forston isn’t completely healthy or struggles in the spring and/or fall, I would not be surprised to see Holmes get pushed ahead of Forston. Curtis Porter played and was impressive as a freshman last season. He’s a squat type DT with a very strong base. He, like Regis, could develop into a very good run stopping DT before his time here is through. Expect to see him in the DT rotation for sure. Jeremy Lewis played some last season, but is still getting to know the game. He has good size and should round out the DT rotation. Luther Robinson redshirted last season so it will be interesting to see what he brings in the fall.
The entire defensive line, both ends and tackles should benefit immensely from the addition of Coach Rick Petri. Petri returns to Miami after coaching in the SEC, and he brings a wealth of teaching experience and knowledge. He helped tutor former Cane greats like Warren Sapp, Kevin Patrick, and Kenny Holmes among others, and should immediately pay dividends by helping our defensive line improve.
Linebackers
1. Colin McCarthy
2. Sean Spence
3. Jordan Futch
4. Ramon Buchanan
5. Shayon Green
6. Kevin Nelson
7. Kylan Robinson
8. CJ Holton
9. Tyrone Cornelius
Redshirt: Travis Williams, Kelvin Cain, James Gaines
LB Thoughts: Coaches addressed this position in recruiting, but there are still some health and limited experience concerns at the LB position. With the departure of Arthur Brown, plans were being made for Colin McCarthy to move from OLB to the MLB. However, injuries to OLBs, Ramon Buchanan and Jordan Futch, have put those plans on hold. McCarthy is the most experienced of Miami’s LBs and could really benefit in the middle as a run stopper. He’s always struggled in coverage and will have to do less of that at MLB, but it will be interesting to see how well he takes on blocks, as he will have to do that quite a bit now as a MLB.
Sean Spence had a stellar season as a freshman, as he was named a Freshman All-America, while also being named the ACC Defensive Rookie of the Year. However, due to nagging injuries, and in my opinion, playing out of position, Spence had a subpar sophomore season. Spence is not a very big LB and he functions much better in space. He’s not adept at taking on blockers and would really benefit from playing the weak side. This way he’s allowed to use his quickness and athleticism to make plays, with having to take on blockers (who are often much bigger and stronger than he is) or cover TEs and RBs (who often beat him in coverage as Spence has more short area quickness than pure speed). Spence wasn’t BAD as a strong side backer, but I think he really wowed as a weak side backer in 2008. Let’s hope coaches feel the same way and put him back to where he is most effective, on the weak side.
Before suffering a torn ACL, Jordan Futch was coming on strong and was looking like he was ready to take the next step. If he can come back 100% healthy in the fall, I’d expect him to take over the strong side LB position allowing Spence to move back to the weak side. Futch is much bigger than Spence and much more physically ready to take on blockers in the run game, yet he is nimble and fleet footed enough to cover TEs and RBs out of the backfield. A lot with Futch will depend on his health and if he is fully recovered from a torn ACL.
Ramon Buchanan is probably our fastest and most athletic LB. After moving down to LB from S, he played a good deal last season after Spence was injured. He’s a contributor and will be in the rotation, but I don’t see him beating out Spence or Futch for a starting spot, if those guys are 100% healthy.
Shayon Green suffered a knee injury that ended his season early in 2009. He’s a big physical kid that played some LB and DE in HS. With Futch and Buchanan out for the spring, and with Arthur Brown leaving the program, Green will get an opportunity to show coaches what he has in the middle. He has a good opportunity, and if he can capitalize on it, he may give coaches something to think about heading into the fall. Both Kylan Robinson and CJ Holton didn’t play much last year outside of special teams. Robinson, while a good athlete, has never really done much in his time at UM. Maybe this spring he’ll open some eyes. Holton is still learning the position after moving to LB from S, but is a big hitter. If he has a big spring, he could find himself in the rotation as well.
Tyrone Cornelius is an early enrollee. While he lacks the ideal size to be an every down OLB early on, he could be very valuable on special teams. I’d look for him to be a contributor on special teams, while he gets bigger and stronger before seeing action as an OLB on a consistent basis. Kevin Nelson is an enigma. A wildcard of sorts when he arrives in the fall, Nelson has all the skills to be a VERY GOOD MLB. He’s also very passionate about the game. However, he’ll need to adjust to the game at this level, and he’ll need to get a bit bigger and stronger before manning the middle full-time. Nelson has made it no secret that he plans on coming in and starting right away. I like his bravado and passionate attitude, and based on his background, I wouldn’t count the kid out. I do expect him to be a contributor this season.
Expect the rest of Miami’s linebacking class (Travis Williams, Kelvin Cain, and Jimmy Gains) to redshirt, unless they find themselves contributing on special teams.
Cornerbacks
1. Brandon Harris
2. Demarcus Van Dyke
3. Brandon McGee
4. Ryan Hill
5. Jamal Reid – could also remain at safety
6. Devont’a Davis
7. Kacy Rodgers
8. Keion Payne
9. Jeremy Davis
CB Thoughts: Depth will most definitely be a concern at CB in the spring. As only Brandon Harris, Demarcus Van Dyke, Brandon McGee, and Ryan Hill return with game experience at CB. Harris is the best of the bunch and was an All-ACC performer, while also garnering third Team All-American honors at CB. Look for Harris to continue his brilliant play and only get better this season. Demarcus Van Dyke has had several ups and downs during his career, but he rebounded from a subpar sophomore year to have a much better, much improved year as a junior. Van Dyke has always had great speed and pretty good cover skills. He also improved his tackling and became a much more physical defender this season, though that is not the strength of his game. Expect to see DVD starting opposite of Brandon Harris when spring practice beings.
Brandon McGee is one of the fastest players on the team, and he played a bit last season. I fully expect him to come into the spring as the Nickel. Ryan Hill is returning for a sixth season after being granted a medical redshirt. In all honesty, he is a blessing to have back game experience will prove to be extremely valuable. I expect him to split time as a nickel and dime defender, while also contributing on special teams. Jamal Reid is an interesting case. He is extremely talented but the dilemma is where does he play, CB or Safety? Look to get that answer in the spring.
This leaves only the new guys to talk about and I see a couple maybe making the roster and a couple redshirting. Between Devont’a Davis, Kacy Rodgers (if healthy), Jeremy Davis, and Keion Payne, 1 or 2 of those guys I can see making the active roster, while the others redshirt. Jeremy Davis is interesting because he will come in as perhaps the fastest player on the team. Because of his speed, he may be immediately involved on special teams, and there is talk of Coach Whipple also trying to use his speed on offense as well. He’ll be a player to watch when fall practice begins in August. I didn’t list any redshirts here as any 1 or 2 of the new guys could make the active roster, or they all could redshirt. Only time will tell.
Safeties
1. Vaughn Telemaque
2. Ray Ray Armstrong
3. Jared Campbell
4. Jo Jo Nicolas
S Thoughts: Depth is 100% a concern at the safety position. As it appears we have only 4 players with game experience at safety excluding Ryan Hill. For depth reasons, I wouldn’t be surprised to see Jamal Reid remain on the roster as a safety, but I think he could be an outstanding corner. At any rate, Vaughn Telemaque returns as the starter at FS. Telemaque had some good moments last season in his first full season as a starter and I expect him to be even better this season. He has good range, pretty good speed, and he isn’t afraid to hit someone (even though he hits people in the knees! HAHAHA).
Ray Ray Armstrong is the enforcer of this group, and at SS, the sky is the limit for this guy. Ray Ray has Sean Taylor like size (6-4, 220) and is a BIG, FEROCIOUS hitter with very good speed. He is an incredible athlete, and I fully expect him to have a break out year. He and Telemaque are going to make one heck of a safety tandem. The surprise of this group is Jared Campbell. Campbell is going to play and it is deserved. He played well last season when given the opportunity, and if Ray Ray for some reason (I can’t see one though) isn’t ready, Campbell is more than able at playing and playing well.
The forgotten man in the shuffle is Jo Jo Nicolas. Jo Jo was injured last season and didn’t play much. He does have experience and has played fairly well when given the chance. It’ll be interesting to see how he comes back from injury, but I think Telemaque and Armstrong are too much for him to take over as a starter. However, I do expect Jo Jo to play a lot this season, and he will contribute.
Well Legion, there you have it, my take on what to expect from the defense in the spring and beyond as we patiently wait for the 2010 season. Remember, these are just my personal thoughts, and I once again encourage you all to express your thoughts and feelings on what you’d like to see from the Canes as we embark upon the upcoming season.
Be on the lookout for Part 3 as I analyze our Special Teams and what to expect from them in the spring.
As always, It’s All About The U and Go Canes!
-bg1906
C.C.M.J.T.K.O