USING CANES BASKETBALL HISTORY TO LOOK AT THE QUESTION OF WHETHER COACH LARRANAGA SHOULD STAY OR GO
by Alpine; March 10, 2020
The Canes actually began fielding a basketball team way back in 1926, but the U dropped it in 1971. In 1985, it was phoenix-time as the Canes rose from the ashes and resumed play. As an Independent, BILL FOSTER led UM the first 5 seasons to a 78-71 record. During this time, Foster never had more than 12 losses and never less than 13 wins.
In 1990, LEONARD HAMILTON took over the reins and posted a 9-19 record.
In 1991, the Canes joined the Big East Conference . . . during their first 3 years there, Hamilton's teams posted Big East records of 1-17, 7-11 and 0-18; his overall record his first 4 years (1990-94) being 34-65.
During Hamilton's next 3 years (1994-97), the team upped it's game slightly, going 26-28 in the Big East; 46-39 overall and making it into the NIT twice, (though bowing out in the 1st round).
In 1997, Hamilton's hard work finally began paying off: 1997-99 the Canes went 41-17 overall; 26-10 in the Big East (2nd place both years) and were invited to the NCAA Championship.
In his last year here (1999-2000), Hamilton's Canes posted a 23-11 overall record, but were 13-3 in the Big East, winning the regular season title . . . they also made it to the Sweet 16 at the NCAA tournament.
Unfortunately, Michael Jordan swooped in with fools gold and our coach left us for the big leagues (where he was employed for about a year, before taking his talents to FSU).
After Hamilton, we spent 4 years under coach PERRY CLARK. His claim to fame was that, in his 2nd year with us, his team reached the NCAA tournament after posting a 10-6 record in the Big East; 24-8 overall. That was followed up by 2 losing seasons (25-33 overall; 8-24 in the Big East) and he was thankfully shown the door.
The Canes joined the ACC in 2004 with a new head coach, FRANK HAITH. Haith recruited decently, but was a totally incompetent coach: in his 7 seasons with the Canes (2004-2011) his overall record was 129-101 and 43-69 in the ACC . . . his best season was his 4th (23-11 overall; 8-8 in the ACC); it was his first and only time reaching .500 in the ACC, which means, he NEVER achieved a winning season in the ACC!
In 2011, we finally got lucky and hired JIM LARRANAGA, who immediately went 9-7 in conference play and indeed, in 6 of his 9 years with Miami, the Canes had a winning ACC record.
But Larranaga's reign is a tale that needs to be divided into 2 parts: the 2011-2018 seasons and the 2018-20 seasons.
In the 7 seasons from 2011 - 2018 his overall record was 161-79 overall, without a single losing season (unlike every other Canes coach). Within the ACC, he had a winning record every year except the 7-11 record in the rebuilding year of 2013/14, after his entire line-up graduated or, in the case of sophomore Shane Larkin, turned pro.
During this 7-year span, a couple notable accomplishments:
- in 4 of the 7 years, the Canes went dancing in the NCAA tournament and TWICE reached the Sweet 16
- in 2 of the other 3 years they went to the NIT, once reaching the Finals (losing heartbreakingly by 2 points)
- in 2012/13 the Canes won both the ACC regular season AND the ACC Tournament Championship, becoming the first (and only) ACC school not named Duke or NC to win both in the same season since 1974 (NC State)
- the Canes were in the top 25 three times during this period (#5 in 2013; #10 in 2016; #22 in 2018)
But in 2018/19, the Canes posted Larranaga's first losing season (14-18), including a 5-13 record within the ACC . . . WHY??!! Did Larranaga suddenly forget how to coach & recruit?
If we look closely at that 2018/19 season, we see:
1- 5-stars Lonnie Walker & Bruce Brown turned pro (+ Jaquan Newton graduated)
2- Larranaga was falsely implicated in an FBI investigation of corruption: recruits fled the uncertainty of major sanctions and we were left with ZERO recruits = ZERO freshmen
3- the NCAA slow-walked the Dewan Hernandez case (arguably our best player); eventually, the NCAA arbitrarily and non-sensically declared him ineligible for the entire season
4- Deng Gak is injured and out for the entire season; Rodney Miller needs to redshirt
This is basically the definition of a "decimated roster".
In 2019/20 (without the FBI & NCAA sticking it to the Canes), Larranaga brings in 3 good recruits + grad transfer, Keith Stone . . . unfortunately, freshmen need time to develop and since there are ZERO sophomores, we wind up not having enough bodies to pick up the slack when injuries hurt the Canes mid-season.
The Canes still manage to pick up 7 ACC regular season wins, which is more than NC!
I mention NC, because in the 17 seasons Roy Williams has coached there, they were #1 in the ACC regular season 9 times! This year, they were 13th! They were in the NCAA tournament every year except 1, (NIT invite) . . . but this year, (unless they become the ACC tournament champion) they will miss the post-season entirely!
So even storied programs can hit a bump in the road!
Or looking at Windy's favorite, FSU's Leonard Hamilton (seen above with FSU Cheer):
1- out of 18 years there, he has only posted 8 winning seasons in the ACC
2a- 2010-12 (his 9th & 10th seasons at FSU) his team had two good seasons, going 11-5 and 12-4 in the ACC (3rd place both seasons)
2b- they follow that up with 7 mediocre seasons, during which FSU only made it above .500 in the ACC twice!
2c- 2019-20 FSU achieves 1st place in the ACC by posting a16-4 record.
Obviously, Hamilton is a very decent coach, but he has not been a basketball god by any means! In my opinion, Larranaga has been the better coach.
So before you dump on Larranaga, get to know your history! Not giving him time to dig himself back out of the hole the NCAA/FBI dug for him would be ridiculous & ignorant.