The Who, a rock band that some of you may have never heard of, once wrote:
I'll tip my hat to the new Constitution
Take a bow for the new revolution
Smile and grin at the change all around
Pick up my guitar and play
Just like yesterday
Then I'll get on my knees and pray
We don't get fooled again
On Canespace there has been an on-going conversation for over 15 years about one central question in college football: "Does Coaching matter?" Now everyone knows that, of course, coaching matters. But how much is the real question?
And the question gets more complicated the deeper you dig. Is the recruiting process more important than coaching? Is it talent more important than coaching? And, how much does coaching really matter after all?
There are several opinions on each of these very important and interesting questions. I am going to separate recruiting and talent from this argument for the sake of this article. I am going to focus only on the coaching variable to try to make this argument very precise and concise.
When Bum Phillips was the head coach of the Houston Oilers back in the day he made the following complimentary statement about the Miami Dolphins head coach Don Shula (paraphrasing): "He can take his players and beat your team, and he can take your players and beat his team."
That statement clearly and directly indicated that coaching was the MOST important element of winning and losing. Most fans are somewhat in between deciding that coaching means all or nothing in winning and losing.
Some say it is 70/30 coaching versus talent. Some say it is 30/70 coaching versus talent. Others go with a 60/40 or 50/50 argument of coaching versus talent. But does anybody really know what the actual equation is? Probably not, and if they say they do, they are probably lying to you.
However, once and for all, we are about to answer this question at the University of Miami. If coaching matters we are certainly about to find out.
Newly hired head coach Mario Cristobal has hired an amazingly talented coaching staff in Coral Gables. A staff so incredibly talented, experienced, motivated and professional that we are frankly surprised that he, or any coach at any college, was able to accomplish this surprising and impressive feat.
So we are about to find out really quickly if Manny Diaz was a fraud and a failure or if the talent on the team was significantly below average.
Simply put, coaching will no longer be the acceptable scapegoat or the excuse, only the talent to win will be. The truth will reveal itself.
Time will tell, but my money is on Mario, and that coaching matters.
Then I'll get on my knees and pray, we don't get fooled again.